This place has become a classic for many locals and our editor even once saw a celebrity there. Come Back Inn is known for its fair prices and amazing food but the warm, welcoming environment is also a part of its charm. Deliciously authentic Italian food is the specialty, in addition to making sure that guests don't leave hungry. Portions are huge and the appetizer list is too delicious to pass up. Though they are now only open for dinner (with many still sad that lunch is no longer served), formal wear is definitely not a requirement for this low-key establishment.

See more: Central Louisville restaurants, Germantown restaurants, Italian restaurants, American restaurants